On the Prospects of Christianity
Sin dudas Bernard
Shaw trasgrede todos los límites y arremete como un toro contra todos. Eso
sí, total libertad para decir lo que quiera, es lo que auspiciamos. Bernard Shaw opinó sobre la cuestión irlandesa, el anarquismo, los
revolucionarios, el matrimonio, así que porque no iba a opinar sobre Cristo y el Cristianismo.
Buscamos la palabra quaint y nos pareció interesante saber sobre la rebelión
de los Anabaptistas en Munster.
… estoy dispuesto a admitir que después de contemplar el mundo y la naturaleza humana durante casi sesenta años, no veo otra salida a la miseria del mundo que la que habría encontrado la voluntad de Cristo si hubiera emprendido la obra de un estadista práctico moderno…
Why not give Christianity a trial?
The question seems a hopeless one after 2000 years of resolute
adherence to the old cry of "Not this man, but Barabbas." Yet it is
beginning to look as if Barabbas was a failure, in spite of his strong right
hand, his victories, his empires, his millions of money, and his moralities and
churches and political constitutions. "This man" has not been a
failure yet; for nobody has ever been sane enough to try his way. But he has
had one quaint
triumph. Barabbas has stolen his name and taken his cross as a standard. There
is a sort of compliment in that. There is even a sort of loyalty in it, like
that of the brigand who breaks every law and yet claims to be a patriotic
subject of the king who makes them. We have always had a curious feeling that
though we crucified Christ on a stick, he somehow managed to get hold of the
right end of it, and that if we were better men we might try his plan. There
have been one or two grotesque attempts at it by inadequate people, such as the
Kingdom
of God in Munster, which was ended by crucifixion so much more
atrocious than the one on Calvary that the bishop who took the part of Annas
went home and died of horror. But responsible people have never made such
attempts. The moneyed, respectable, capable world has been steadily
anti-Christian and Barabbasque since the crucifixion; and the specific doctrine
of Jesus has not in all that time been put into political or general social
practice. I am no more a Christian than Pilate was, or you, gentle reader;
and yet, like Pilate, I greatly prefer Jesus to Annas and Caiaphas; and I am
ready to admit that after contemplating the world and human nature for nearly
sixty years, I see no way out of the world's misery but the way which would
have been found by Christ's will if he had undertaken the work of a modern
practical statesman. Pray do not at this early point lose patience with me
and shut the book. I assure you I am as sceptical and scientific and modern a
thinker as you will find anywhere. I grant you I know a great deal more about
economics and politics than Jesus did, and can do things he could not do. I am
by all Barabbasque standards a person of much better character and standing,
and greater practical sense. I have no sympathy with vagabonds and talkers who
try to reform society by taking men away from their regular productive work and
making vagabonds and talkers of them too; and if I had been Pilate I should
have recognized as plainly as he the necessity for suppressing attacks on the
existing social order, however corrupt that order might be, by people with no
knowledge of government and no power to construct political machinery to carry
out their views, acting on the very dangerous delusion that the end of the
world was at hand. I make no defence of such Christians as Savonarola and John
of Leyden: they were scuttling the ship before they had learned how to build a
raft; and it became necessary to throw them overboard to save the crew. I say
this to set myself right with respectable society; but I must still insist that
if Jesus could have worked out the practical problems of a Communist
constitution, an admitted obligation to deal with crime without revenge or
punishment, and a full assumption by humanity of divine responsibilities, he
would have conferred an incalculable benefit on mankind, because these
distinctive demands of his are now turning out to be good sense and sound
economics.Shaw in 1914
I say distinctive, because his common humanity and his subjection
to time and space (that is, to the Syrian life of his period) involved his
belief in many things, true and false, that in no way distinguish him from other
Syrians of that time. But such common beliefs do not constitute specific
Christianity any more than wearing a beard, working in a carpenter's shop, or
believing that the earth is flat and that the stars could drop on it from
heaven like hailstones. Christianity interests practical statesmen now because
of the doctrines that distinguished Christ from the Jews and the Barabbasques
generally, including ourselves… (Preface
to Androcles and the Lion On the Prospects of Christianity, by Bernard Shaw)
Traducción
… No soy más cristiano que Pilato, o tú, amable
lector; y sin embargo, como Pilato, prefiero mucho más a Jesús que a Anás y
Caifás; y estoy dispuesto a admitir que después de contemplar el mundo y la
naturaleza humana durante casi sesenta años, no veo otra salida a la miseria
del mundo que la que habría encontrado la voluntad de Cristo si hubiera
emprendido la obra de un estadista práctico moderno…
… si Jesús hubiera podido resolver los problemas
prácticos de una constitución comunista, una obligación admitida de tratar con
el crimen sin venganza o castigo, y una plena asunción por parte de la
humanidad de las responsabilidades divinas, habría conferido un beneficio
incalculable a la humanidad, porque estas demandas distintivas de los suyos
ahora están resultando ser de buen sentido y buena economía.
Para saber
Kingdom
of God in Munster
The
Münster rebellion fue un intento de los Anabaptistas radicales de establecer un
gobierno comunal en la ciudad alemana de Münster,
en 1535.
La ciudad estuvo bajo el gobierno Anabaptista desde 1934 hasta su caída en
1535.
Vocabulario
Quaint:
attractive because of being unusual and especially old-fashioned:
A quaint
old cottage
Quaint:
pintoresco.
Artículos relacionados
… promovió la eugenesia, la reforma al alfabeto, y
se opuso a la religión organizada. Se volvió impopular al denunciar a ambos bandos
en la Primera Guerra Mundial… G.
B. Shaw
The political necessity for killing him is precisely
like that for killing the cobra or the tiger: he is so ferocious or
unscrupulous that if his neighbors do not kill him he will kill or ruin his
neighbors… About
Killing for Political Reasons
En una época en que Gran Bretaña era la mayor
potencia económica y política del mundo, Dickens señaló la vida del olvidado
dentro de la sociedad… Charles
Dickens
Comentario
Difícil, ¿no es cierto? Y lo de arriba es solo una
pequeña introducción. ¿Los Barrabás dominaron el mundo por 2000 años? ¿Cristo
era solo un teórico? Como católico no practicante, lo que me gusta de Cristo, a
través de las enseñanzas de la biblia, es el ejemplo de bondad y de amor que
brinda a todos. Incluso a Bernard Shaw.
Pero mejor lean todo el tratado para poder opinar a conciencia.
De la web
Increíble video de George Bernard Shaw, dando una pequeña entrevista en su casa, a los
90 años. Es imperdible
He's 90 George Bernard Shaw
(1946), segment from British Pathé
Si
te gustó esto compartílo con tus amigos.
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario
Deja aquí tus mensajes, comentarios o críticas. Serán bienvenidos